42 Responses

  1. Kashmira at | | Reply

    simone needs to lose those tights. looks horrid

  2. kayshika at | | Reply

    karishma’s r so hot!

  3. Glitzy.Apple at | | Reply

    Karisma looks fabulous. She is wearing a hugo boss skirt from the current collection. I got myself one recently… :)
    No words for Simone. Its hard to compare when you are put up against a STAR.

  4. Megha at | | Reply

    karisma’s is marginally better just bcuz seeing pink shoes with black tights makes the pink even more tacky than it already is

    but highlighter pink for shoes for me is a no-no

  5. Flower Power at | | Reply

    love Karisma’s

  6. Aarthi at | | Reply

    Karishma for sure! I am tired of seeing Simone in leggings!
    Karishma’s pumps look divine with that black outfit…though she seems to prefer black for her clothes, she totally rocks this look with those hot pink pumps!!

  7. Dimple at | | Reply

    Karisma looks better than her usual skinny look, the dress fits well.. and shoes are okay…who is simone? and why is she here?

  8. mia at | | Reply

    Karishma looks hot! I normally dislike pink shoes but she’s won me over with this look.

  9. arbitary at | | Reply

    Neck up – Simone
    Neck Down – Karisma

  10. pdaervo at | | Reply

    I LOVE LOVE LOVE Simone’s dress and hair and makeup and MARC JACOBS(<3) bag and DRESS, but the tights and the shoes don’t go
    …Karisma looks scarily like a flight attendent- and how the hell do paparazzi get on a plane…
    her outfit is nice though, as are her shoes- but she looks so plasitcy that it’s hard for me to like her
    I’ve always liked Simone for having a distinct style, and I AM IN LOVE WITH HER DRESS- who is it by P&P, ladies (gentlemen)?

  11. k=kirthi at | | Reply

    karishma looks like that in the flight?? omg.. i hope she never sees me travelling! i look like a mop! lol

  12. dn at | | Reply

    Karisma looks good, but she is totally glammed up, and Simone has bare minimum make-up and still looks cute. So we can’t really compare. But yes, the pink shoes on Simone look bad.

  13. amisha at | | Reply

    karishma has it going for her from top to toe.

  14. sdn at | | Reply

    Would like to see Karisma in some bright colors.. tired of the black and whites

  15. Anastasia at | | Reply

    I prefer Simone- her look would be good with black shinny jeans as well…KK’s nothing out of the ordinary…The kind of outfit you could wear to work (sans the perky pumps)…..Besides, I think Simone’s prettier of the two…KK (and her sibling) look more like mannequins to be- insipid and ghastly pale…No offence intended…:)

  16. polly at | | Reply

    simone all the way! karishma looks horrid

  17. anju at | | Reply

    when i was younger i was totally mad about the whole boho look like what simone is wearing. now that i’m older, i love karishma’s polished outfits. i’m not ancient, btw, i’m around karishma’s age :-)

  18. Megha at | | Reply

    that picture was from a promotional flight for the show nach baliye – hence there were paparazzi around and she was dressed like that

  19. Rose at | | Reply

    i luvvv karishmas shoes.. theyre so sexii

  20. nisha at | | Reply

    I love Simone’s outfit, where is it from? It looks like Phillip lim but a few season back…

  21. B at | | Reply

    I prefer Simone’s look but the pointy shoes with tights don’t look good at all

  22. yaya at | | Reply

    i like how they made they’re outfit more colorful and i like Simone dress, but i don’t like her pointy shoes
    I prefer Karishma’ shoes

  23. Janvi at | | Reply

    I like Simone’s dress but Karishma’s shoes:)…but overall Simone looks better(love her hair).

  24. Priyanka D at | | Reply

    Karishma looks fab. Is she on some kind of diet that works only for her, I mean, look at her.. she looks as sexy and svelte as she did before she had a kid. Awesome. Love her shoes. Simone’s shoes don’t go with the outfit. Take off the tights Simone, you look gorgeous without them.

  25. annie at | | Reply

    Karisma looks like a sexy secretary while Simone looks good knees -up. She needs some color on her cheeks and the tights and shes need to go. Karisma looks pretty but her outfit is so over the top.

  26. annie at | | Reply

    If u guys observe carefully, Karishma has actually matched (or asked to match) her shoes with the color of seats of the aeroplane….

  27. jaishree at | | Reply

    I loveeeeeeee Karishmas pumps…I so want them!
    Arent they christian louboutins?

  28. Rehana at | | Reply

    Lolo wins hands down overall!
    Simone is a pretty lady she shd stop wearing thsoe thights to make her look awful! Her top is nice too.

  29. nafisa at | | Reply

    i dig simone’s outfit minus the black leggins

  30. achla at | | Reply

    She is in economy?

  31. sunny at | | Reply

    Simone should have gone with mary janes and no tights. Karishma looks absolutely FAB. Love the shirt, love the skirt, love the look.

  32. Peskyone at | | Reply

    Simone – original
    Karishma – contrived.

  33. Adit at | | Reply

    dimple, Simone is a celeb, and a socialite in Bombay, she is also a very beautiful woman….married to Fahad Samar for 10 years, who has his own production company and is Ismail merchants newphew.

  34. Surbhi at | | Reply

    Karisma looks like a secretary and Simone looks like her attendant
    kidding, they both are great ladies, so both win

  35. Jeanie at | | Reply

    karishma is almost always super chic… love her!
    as for this simone chick… if i were her, i probably would have paired that ensemble with some round toe flats or mary janes!

  36. ChaltaPhirta at | | Reply

    anyday simone… such an individualistic dresser who knows how to play up her strengths…plus i have a weakness for boho chic…. karishma’s look is that of a mannequin, there’s no personality to make it interesting

  37. Prakriti at | | Reply

    The ex-factor(http://www.highheelconfidential.com/nandita-mahtani-arjun-rampal-party-chanel-clutch/) seems to continue with the shoes too(the color) ;)

  38. karishma g at | | Reply

    i really want karishma’s shoes. are they louboutins?

  39. soniya at | | Reply

    karisma is effortless. love it!

  40. Protyasha at | | Reply

    I love karisma’s entire look. I hadn’t seen her look this good in a while now.

  41. ananya_s at | | Reply

    ohh man love d dress dat simone is wearing….vvry feminine n pretty!!she’d hav looked gd, hd she accessorized it differently!!n ooohhh, dose high-waisted skirts……

  42. Natasha at | | Reply

    the pink shoes ruined both looks …!!
    otherwise i love karisma’s style always !!

Leave a Reply