39 Responses

  1. ramizi at | | Reply

    Sad to admit but I feel like you guys are starting to lose your touch. This version is the least impressive of the lot. Having a billowy dress at that length ends up hiding the shape and does nothing for the wearer. The other two versions at least had some provision to show off shapely legs/ankles/the collar bone and shoulders. Cinched at the waist would’ve made the other two marginally better. This one completely blows…

  2. dn at | | Reply

    God no.. the dress looks great on the runway, but on Anuj it looks like a white bedsheet.

  3. dn at | | Reply

    Sorry I meant on Priya Tanna it looks like a bedsheet.

  4. charan at | | Reply

    I absolutely hate it on Priya. It give no shape or structure to her already curvy body… it looks like gravity worked on her hard.
    I love it on the runway though…

  5. apsara77 at | | Reply

    i am sorry, but this looks like a shapeless satin bed sheet and does nothing to enhance Priya’s body and makes her look bigger than she probably is.

  6. m at | | Reply

    it’s WTHEYY.. for me..like the dress on model, love that color..
    but on Priya..it looks plain UGLY

  7. deewani at | | Reply

    that’s just a big sateen sheet wrapped around her body!

  8. Rania at | | Reply

    It looks like nightwear to me, not particularly liking the rosette detail. And the runway looks better than the white one

  9. Baby at | | Reply

    it looks like a satin bed sheet.

  10. Pri at | | Reply

    I’d have to disagree on this dress looking good on and off the runway. It’s got no shape whatsoever. As if she just got out of bed and bunched up a sheet around her. It makes Priya Tanna look heavy around the hips and legs. On the runway we can see the model’s slim figure only because she’s walking and the fabric is hitting against her body.

  11. Soni at | | Reply

    Sorry guys, I disagree…I really don’t like it on Priya..looks like a white satin bedsheet to me..

  12. Saya at | | Reply

    Hate it on Priya. Making her body look heavier and boobs all saggy. The dress fairs -marginally- on the runway too.

  13. Nadia at | | Reply

    Agree with all the aforementioned comments! Its only because the model is so gorgeous that the dress looks half-decent. Very unflattering!!

  14. Amy at | | Reply

    Agree with all the above comments, it does look like she wrapped a satin bedsheet around her.

  15. Carol at | | Reply

    This is not even a dress. Like everyone said, it looks like a satin bed sheet. I think you all are losing it.

  16. Anu at | | Reply

    I hate the white…its so shiny…and the black lining is such a bad contrat to the white…these sort tent dresses look better on tall skinny people…and if u absolutely have to wear it, shortening it and cinching it at the waist would help

  17. Nick at | | Reply

    The white version on Priya Tanna ..may I say, looks like a bedsheet hanging on someone (someone who sleeps in their b’day suit perhaps), the earrings are dated. I like the runway version and the other pink dress.

  18. Nick at | | Reply

    Priya Tanna also looks bloated or its something else.. I didn’t realize it was her

  19. Monika at | | Reply

    I actually quite like this dress and think she looks great in it. So she’s not a size zero, whats wrong with that? I love the cut and form of this dress.

  20. KK at | | Reply

    This dress is ugly and it makes Priya look HUGE!!! I agree with the bedsheet comments!! Even I can make a dress like that .. this is fashion?!?! NEXT!

  21. Joy at | | Reply

    satin when used incorrectly (as on priya tanna) ends up looking like sleepwear… the knot looks very random to me and the outfit in entirety looks like a huge ugly bib..the designer’s never impressed me much…DIY clothes do not cut it with me..

  22. RB at | | Reply

    its a sack

  23. Tara at | | Reply

    Totally disagree! The dress is way ahead of its times! Just because its not the conventional fitted one doesn’t mean its a bed sheet. Wake up ladies! Lack of structure is a good thing – very Japanese! Priya looks good! Give the editor of Vogue some credit – she knows what she is doing.

  24. paris at | | Reply

    how can u guys like it on priya??? like, really! it looks terrible on her! marginally better on the model… on the whole, its a very disappointing dress!

  25. Megha at | | Reply

    i don’t like the dress on her for sure
    but i like the critisism again P&P even less
    just cause someone might have a different opinion and like a dress a lot of ppl don’t doesnt mean they are ‘losing their touch’
    definitely a tad harsh
    sorry about my being harsh…i get a bit upset when i read comments like that (e.g. i cant believe you guys like this – what is wrong with u – type of things) – and i have seen many of late.
    feels like this website and P&P’s efforts are being taken for granted

    1. the mad momma at | | Reply

      I agree. This is P&P’s website and I dont understand readers/commenters who think someone is ‘losing their touch’ or ‘working for vogue’ just because they prefer something. It shows a definite lack of maturity

  26. whizbabe at | | Reply

    Do you guys work for Vogue? Because you always seem to have unfairly positive comments for Mrs. Tanna

  27. preeths at | | Reply

    what an uninspiring piece of.. umm.. cloth!!! (i choose not to call it a dress)

    its horrible on both! i wouldnt be caught dead wearing this! and Ms. Tanna needs to invest like..NOW.. THIS MOMENT!! in good innerwear :O

  28. preeths at | | Reply

    PnP, how come your okay with that fact that this cloth is VERY see through on Ms. Tanna. Normanlly you shoot down every celeb for it ..lolll ;)

  29. FARAH at | | Reply

    it’s definately not for priya’s body type but i would happily wear the dress. me like!!

  30. siddharth at | | Reply

    After reading your comment policy that we should not call someone fat or ugly, but rather that the person doesnt dress well for her body or age, I would like to say that Priya Tanna doesnt dress well for her body and age. I like to say what I feel, if you like the comment post it, if you dont like it dont post it, I never complain that my comment was moderated or not published.

  31. Shruti at | | Reply

    Mmm… everyone makes mistakes. Priya Tanna made one… but I admire the confidence she is emitting in this pic… The dress does’nt seem to dampen her spirits.

  32. pdaervo at | | Reply

    While I like the dress (moreso in the blush tone) it is NOT for herr body type…at all
    what a dissapointment for Vouge India

  33. VirgoVixen at | | Reply

    This dress is not forgiving at all, like it the runway colour more, the white makes it look even MORE like a bed sheet lol:P It does nothing for Priya

  34. rupal at | | Reply

    Fab Fab Fab

  35. Carton at | | Reply

    please tell the lady editor to invest in some undergarments to uplift those babies. my nanny 20 yrs back had better style than her.

  36. diya at | | Reply

    My reaction when i saw this was…”eeeek”!….what was she thinking?

  37. kasthuri at | | Reply

    It looks worse than a maxi…

    1. amaya at | | Reply

      i actually quite like it . i mean the whole point of the dress is to show that it CAN look good on everybody, irrespective of their size. hhaha :p now , everyone cant be a skinny model in a tight dress. i don’t know , but i think she pulls it off pretty well.

Leave a Reply