38 Responses

  1. Sej at | | Reply

    Hands down Sonam. I don’t like her gloves – wish she had worn a pair of what Mugdha is sporting but aside from that her hair and that shade lipstick totally wins the look for her. Mugdha’s hair looks like a hot mess and I wish they had toned up her lip color a bit.

  2. hira at | | Reply

    October issue of Cosmo 2009 had Deepika on the main cover with a red gown and the supplement issue of the same month was the above cover. with Sonam in a red gown

    wonder why you didnt do a cover war then!! ah I get it. Cos Deepika totally rocked that cover! Of course you dont like anyone one-upping your beloved fashionista. And when Deepika is seen in something even remotelty similar to what Sonam has worn before, you fall over yourselves doing Ditto editions day in and day out..

    bias much??

    1. Chocolate Martini at | | Reply

      Because Deepika and Sonam were not wearing the SAME dress, Mugdha and Sonam are. Besides, PnP did a face-off between Jaquelin Fernandes and Sonam Kapoor, where they gave it to Jackie. This whole Sonam-hating on the blog is getting a bit…silly (I mean all of the comments in general, not just this one). The fashionista label was NOT meant to be taken so seriously.

      1. hira at | | Reply

        @ chocolate martini
        In the same vein, the unnecessary Sonam fawning is also getting quite silly, don’t you think? I can post a few prev Sonam Deepika faceoffs here, sonam on a airbrushed mag vs deepika at a film shoot. or faceoffs between the two just because deepika wore a pink dress and gladiators, but really don’t have the patience to dig into it. Moreover several of the regular old readers have pointed out this bias time and again.
        And before I’m branded as a zealous deepika fan by all the zealous sonam fans, I’m not in my teens anymore for being a fan of anyone for that matter.

        1. simran at | | Reply

          its their blog , they can be all baised they want to be :)

        2. Saya at | | Reply

          Agreed, Hira. Most of them here will agree on the bias.

    2. Tina at | | Reply

      I don’t think Deepika was wearing the same Ferragamo gown so why should there have been a cover war then? She wasn’t even wearing a gown, she was wearing a short dress.

    3. ko at | | Reply

      completly agree.. sonam looks wayyyyy photoshpped her.. mugda’s face is better. don’t like the booby show

  3. rr at | | Reply

    neither. but if forced to make a choice, then mughda.

  4. AnI at | | Reply

    no competition exists….sonam wins d race by miles…

  5. Rohini at | | Reply

    SONAM. Mugdha’s hair looks messy, not punk-messy, just..messy. And I like the lightness of the Cosmo cover.

  6. diptiN at | | Reply

    not a fan of outfits with strangely placed cut outs. BV has a lot of them this year. The fit is much better on sonam

  7. shaila at | | Reply

    really nice dress. imo, mugdha looks better in it. sonam looks so plastic here.

  8. kk at | | Reply

    cosmo covers r so typical, always t same nothing interesting, but hey mugdha rocks here wth t diff look, only she can carry off this, put Sonam in tht look, n think wt mess it wl b.. sm people cnt carry few looks but Mugdha rocks all… bravo… my vote wth mugdha for giving us Novelty…

  9. ms. meow at | | Reply

    I like Sonam because she looks classier. I don’t like the sagging b**b we see on Mugdha. Maybe it is a bad angle, but just doesn’t work.

  10. roma at | | Reply

    sonam…her fashion sense is just amazing…i wish i had that

  11. SS at | | Reply

    Sonam looks very glamorous, and I love the little tribute to Madonna by way of the gloves (or maybe I am just obsessed with last night’s epsiode of Glee!)

  12. Dona at | | Reply

    I am not able to fathom why two different magazines will have the same designer and dress on the front page? Is there a sudden dearth of designers in tinsel town?

  13. Vanaja at | | Reply

    Sonam all the way. Such a beautiful figure and face…..

  14. Dips at | | Reply

    Sonam, undoubtedly! And I’m not even a Sonam fan. I get that they’re going for 2 different looks here…but I like Sonam’s look better. Very classy and she rocks the red lipstick. I noticed that when she was on the filmfare cover. I wish I could pull off the red lipstick look. I look too made-up:(!

  15. charan at | | Reply

    I would like mugdha’s better if her hair accessories/feathers weren’t so ewww… it takes away from the classic look of the dress. So this time around, i have to pick sonam.

  16. Bhavana at | | Reply

    there’s something just odd about both of the covers..its either they way they are posing with the gown..or the gown doesn’t work on either of them..or maybe i just don’t like the ferragamo gown..i’m not sure but something isn’t working here at all

  17. HHCPANKHA at | | Reply

    there is too much going on in Andpersand…
    the cover is a hodgepodge of the dress the titles in same color…
    the hair style…ughh

  18. aisha a at | | Reply

    sonam fares well here….the brighter tone work a little better…mughda’s hair has too much going on…tone it down a bit and she will look good int eh darker version with her dusky skin..

  19. *S* at | | Reply

    No doubts….Sonam all the way. Love the punk rockish feel…classy yet a rocker.

  20. Priyanka at | | Reply

    I’m a die-hard Sonam fan.i breathe her.
    but, this one goes to Mugdha for me. There’s just a bit more going on in her covern than in Sonam’s.

    1. monika at | | Reply

      so right!!

  21. RS at | | Reply

    Mugdha’s skin tone looks so good. Now if only her hair didn’t resemble a crow’s nest, this would have been a totally different story. In summary, Sonam wins.

  22. Kish at | | Reply

    It’s not about sonam or mugdha- essentially, the question is, which styling is better?
    You could switch the girls on the magazines and the answer would remain the same (for me at least): Sonam. The andsomething magazine seems to have gotten the ‘punk romantic’ equation wrong.

    1. Kish at | | Reply

      Sorry not Sonam, I meant Cosmo.

  23. Shivangi at | | Reply

    Mugdha,SOnam looks too much photoshopped here.

  24. Dee_dior at | | Reply

    Awesome cover Sonam! Likes!!

  25. Tee at | | Reply

    Sideboob alert!

  26. Maya at | | Reply

    Of course Sonam! But what is with the playboy bunny look in and?

  27. ASHOOO at | | Reply


  28. gagan at | | Reply

    sonam sonam sonam…. mugdha looks like a …..

  29. Star at | | Reply

    Sonam reminds me of Prachi Desai in rock on.

  30. Gris at | | Reply

    sonam…for sure

Leave a Reply