21 Responses

  1. Kimmy at | | Reply

    Not feeling either pair of shoes. But I like how Karishma wears the top; it’s very streamlined and clean.

  2. PeachBellini at | | Reply

    I don’t think they are wearing the same item, though granted that they are very similar. Karishma’s is a top. It cannot be worn as a dress, especially considering that she is shorter than many women, so the length of the top will be even shorter on most women than on karishma.

    that said, i like neither version.

    1. bluebird at | | Reply

      correct. karisma’s is not a dress!

      1. emem at | | Reply

        agree – doesnt look like the same to me

  3. Dee_dior at | | Reply

    Karisma’s look is so classy! She’s one helluva Fashion Diva!
    She carries it off so elegantly and never tries too hard

  4. maya at | | Reply

    love Stella McCartney’s shoes much more. but both the ladies look good.

  5. pdaervo at | | Reply

    In my eyes, both of them carry about the same level of interest…
    Off to comment on something else

  6. diptiN at | | Reply

    do not like either, but the white shoes on Karisma who I think is a very classy dress is a big tumbs down

  7. pan at | | Reply

    karishma minus shoes

  8. somya at | | Reply

    karishma looks stunning
    do not like the shoes though…the shoes and ear rings go hand in hand and the top and jeans are a pair…the dress is amazing..should have changed the shoes

  9. priya at | | Reply

    no contest. Karisma wears this wayyy better except for that “I HAVE MY ARM STUCK TO MY SIDE” pose.

  10. tan ta da! at | | Reply

    ok those Stella McCartney Mesh Sandals are pure beauty!!!

  11. monika at | | Reply

    I don’t like this

  12. stuti at | | Reply

    This is a different dress, with a very similar lattice pattern.

  13. aishwarya at | | Reply

    karishma definately luks better than kate walsh
    she s more classic

  14. LuvAlways at | | Reply

    Do the designers sell such variations (as top and dress) or do our people take a dress and alter it and make it a top? How does it work? I see that several times the same thing appears as an altered version on someone else.

  15. Tania at | | Reply

    Karishma is such a stunner..every thing she wears looks good on her.

  16. saloni at | | Reply

    karisma anytime..

  17. Lea at | | Reply

    Never heard of Karisma whoever the heck she is.

    Kate Walsh for sure. She’s gorgeous. And it has to be a dress cos Kate is like 5’10 plus heels.

Leave a Reply