Photoshoot Wars!
June 10th, 2009 at 10:41 am . by PayalIts not the first time we have seen a certain outfit make its way to multiple photoshoots. Earlier we had seen Freida’s Marc Jacobs outfit make its way on Sonam Kapoor (see here ) and now High School Musical star Vanessa Hudgens was spotted wearing the same Louis Vuitton dress seen first on Freida on the Vogue cover.
Question is, which shoot do you like better?
|
Left: Frieda Pinto on Vogue India
Right: Vanessa Hudgens on Instyle
without a doubt vanessa hudgens
its amazing how she manages to look cute and edgy at the same time
also her makeup is gorgeous
freida’s louder makeup, hair and the necklace take away the focus from the dress
They seriously messed up frieda in her photo shoot. She has a seriously attractive skin tone and they’ve completely washed her out. Instead of playing to her strengths (they chose the wrong makeup, dress, camera angle) they’ve put together a generic photo shoot theme that they would’ve put on anyone that came their way that month.
Vanessa in comparison looks relaxed and far less contrived. She wins by a mile.
And that dress is so fugly!
definitely frieda! Her shoot is all dramatic and she looks beautifully sharp. Vanessa’s pose is too weird for me toi warm up the shoot
I like Vanessa’s shoot much better than Frieda’s. V’s pic is showing more of the dress and is understated and chic. The Vogue cover is way to messy. I have seen very beautiful and simple vogue covers such as the one Priyanka was on. Herhair did all the talking. Frieda’s dress is hardly visable and the dark lips, the pin-up girl hair, and that necklace aren’t looking good all at once, maybe seperately.
freida! i love the cover.
i dont like frieda at all….. she is a wannabe
As much as I hate Vanessa Hudgens, I must grudgingly admit here photoshoot is MUCH better than that of Freida’s. With a dress that is so elaborate, any accessories would ruin it, and Freida’s monstrosity of a necklace definitely does that. Freida’s lovely skin is completely washed out, while Vanessa is literally glowing.
There is a no comparison if you asked me;Vanessa by a mile.Her shoot is natural,real and as osmeone above has metioned the Vogue shoot is extremely predictable and generic.
It’s so clear in this case that both Frieda and the Vogue team had solely a one dimensional brief in mind-To project Frieda as the anti-thesis of Slumdog(There is so much more one can elaborate on this point but the comment would become very long lol)
If one goes back to Frieda pre-Slumdog she had a mind-numbingly banal and mundanee sense of fashion in all aspects.Now she’s in a place where she has to deliver in order to maintain the pedestal media has given her and also to make sure all potential oppurtunities come her way due to the attention.The reason I bring this point up is fashion is all about sensibility and personality and Vanessa’s personality is already such that she looks at home in such an editorial.She has this interest and understanding of fashion in her daily life.Frieda does not thus comes accross as ‘generic’.
Yes Frieda has changed her fashion choices but those choices(case in point red carpets/events) are not a reflection of personal sensibility rather a sense of wanting to do it right.Thus,even now her choices are safe and textbook like as they are not her own expressions.
Gosh that was looong!lol
please excuse the spelling errors lol I had so much to say I didn’t want to go through the grammar check process lol
This kind of heavy make up makes Frieda look horrible(imho). Frieda looks ok with natural make up.
Frieda is more of a girl-next-door type, me thinks. She looks great on a red carpet, but photoshoots aren’t her forte. As much as it kills me to say it, Vanessa looks much better here.
However, when it comes to rocking a red carpet, Frieda has got her by a mile (because she actually SMILES >:l )
While I think Frieda looks a million times PRETTIER, I’d have to pick Vanessa’s shoot. She looks happy, fresh, sexy and cute at the same time. Her body and the dress are made for each other!
totally agree with pdaervo.
Scarlett Johannsen was also weraing this dress in the new French Elle and looked AWFUL.
I prefer the dress on Vanessa. Frankly, I do not see what all the “Frieda Fuss” is all about. She has average features and she doesn’t impress me, at least from what I have seen of her in interviews. People like Bips or Priyanka would be better exports to the Hollywood.
don’t like either look or girls.
vanessa is soooo overrated!!!
No way its Frieda…she looks horrible with loud makeup..she shud always stick to natural..so tht her skin glows…anyway she was one film success girl!! whrz she btw these days ;) ;)
deffently vanessa hudgens she is a great person and she have the perfect body for it
@ Lalitha
I disagree with you