42 Responses

  1. biba at | | Reply

    OMG is that even Lindsay?? Talk about Photoshop overdose… btw yes totally agree, Kareena wins this for me too thanks to her natural makeup. But I do dig the yellow shadow on Lindsay.

  2. Kav at | | Reply

    is that really lindsay lohan? .is this what she looks like? then who’s the woman with the freckles and zoned out look we see on ET and TMZ? too much photoshop IMO
    lindsay looks more dramatic and i am not a big fan of kareena, but kareena wins this imo…at least she is recognizable…

  3. CocoNUT at | | Reply

    Kareena wins this one by a long shot!!

    I like her natural makeup and the way she poses is sooo sexy

    Lindsay on the other hand…looks stupid posing like that, and the makeup is a little too matchy with the outift

  4. kahlu at | | Reply

    I actually like the edginess in Lindsey’s look, including the yellow shadow, which they tried to mute with the flower.

  5. ron at | | Reply

    sorry but i preferred lindsay’s, kareena’s is way too photoshopped especially the smile, lindsay has taken the dress and made it more fun and i like tht there is a real background to the picture. kareena looked she posed for a pic while on holiday

  6. Saya at | | Reply

    I prefer LiLo!

  7. s at | | Reply

    The dress works well only on the model.
    even though the colors are fabulous it seem to be the type that can work only on models( not even size zero body types!!!), which i do think is bad on the designer’s aprt:

  8. KT at | | Reply

    can’t decide.. i think they both look equally good (or bad) :)

  9. Richa at | | Reply

    it Kareena all the way for me…!!!! her makeup does wonders here…

  10. CD at | | Reply

    Linsay Lohan, in my opinion.

  11. CD at | | Reply

    Oops, I meant Lindsay Lohan

  12. Mansi at | | Reply

    Kareena wins hands down !!!

  13. Su at | | Reply

    I like Lilo better, edgy, curvy and funky! Kareena’s frame is too twiggy and make up is bland, no-fun..
    I guess the photoshoot theme and styling is completely different!!

  14. Jems at | | Reply

    I personally like LiLos styling… more editorial and less cute girl hanging out at the mall

  15. Indianlover at | | Reply

    I’ll take Kareena anyday over Ms. Lohan.

  16. high heel follower at | | Reply

    Lindsay looks way better. She totally brings an edgy and young feel to the dress. Kareena looks boring and old.

  17. Anita at | | Reply


  18. Marya at | | Reply

    Despite being a Kareena fan I have to give this to Lindsay. The styling is wayyy better. The accessories and make up brings this outfit to life. Kareena looks like a blank canvas with the dress on! But Kareena your body rocks honey ;)

  19. suchi at | | Reply

    what! this is lindsay lohan! she looks unrecognizable

  20. suchi at | | Reply

    kareena was waaaay tooo skinny those days, glad to see her looking so much better now

  21. Random at | | Reply

    erm, that doesnt look like Lohan to me

  22. Carol at | | Reply

    Sorry but Kareena looks awful in this photo and that does not look like Lindsay at all. So I vote neither.

  23. Sam at | | Reply

    Kareena wins, no contest!

    Bebo looks so fresh.

  24. saba at | | Reply

    i disagree…..i actually like lindsays look, much more fun!

  25. Missy Mochi at | | Reply

    Lindsay looks much better!

  26. kj at | | Reply

    Are you sure that Lindsay??? She is completely unrecognizable… Though I like the look better than Kareena’s

  27. Prem Rogue at | | Reply

    I hate the dress but I think it looks better on Lindsay or whoever that is. The make-up, flower, bracelet, pose…all work, maybe because they draw attention away from the ugly dress. On Kareena it’s just the dress and her make-up-less zombie-like face that compete for your attention, and neither are all that attractive. On her it looks like she is wearing a rotting omelette.

  28. shonali at | | Reply

    kareena rocks this outfit. lindsay looks too vapid for me.

  29. fopa at | | Reply

    kareena wins for me!

  30. Shikha at | | Reply

    I would say Lindsay….i dint like kareena’s expression at all and the dress doesnt look nice on her…

  31. Nick at | | Reply

    If that is Lindsay then.. GOD yea she must have caked up some makeup! I don’t like the outfit anyway.. the yellow on the skirt is simply blinding and the sleeves didn’t have to be a different colour. Kareena looks too skinny and Lilo who is another Miss skinny … hmm I like her eyes acctually and probably the accessories she has on as well.

  32. heridisnot at | | Reply

    I like Lindsay, and KK does look alright too. However her head looks way too big for the body. That distracts….

  33. Rezia at | | Reply

    Kareena’s shoot is more natural and LiLo’s is edgy. The dress works eother way if you ask me.
    But props to Kareena for LOOKING like Kareena. Lindsay’s picture is not Lindsay at all. I mean c’mon (!!!!) why even bother her for shooting this if the image that results is so far removed from reality?

  34. pdaervo at | | Reply

    really commentors? I think Kareena has this one in the bag
    Lindsay is just trying too hard at everything these days…man, I watched the parent trap two days ago, and it made me sad :(

  35. Sharin at | | Reply

    Kareena does look like she’s just posing while on holiday. Also Kareena’s face looks way more retouched than Lindsay’s does. Like the styling on Lindsay more.. so my vote goes to her!

  36. NJ at | | Reply

    Lindsay wins this hands down! Kareena looks like an emaciated wax statue.

  37. Nams at | | Reply

    I vote for Bebo… she looks more chic..

  38. sonia at | | Reply

    Is that Lindsay Lohan?? Looks more like Liv Tyler….

  39. tito at | | Reply

    karina’s head is lookin way too big,nd de dress is makin it too prominent me think..

  40. Shweta at | | Reply

    I would have to say Kareena, Lindsay’s yellow eyes just don’t work and so does not look like her, overdose of makeup and photoshop

  41. ahana at | | Reply

    it gotta be our desiee gurl!!..hands down ….she jus looks so gorgeous!!! …:)))

  42. amna at | | Reply

    kareena jus looks like she is deprived of food!!! heehhaheahe but i like the styling on the other pic!!

Leave a Reply