27 Responses

  1. nalini at | | Reply

    twinkle wins this round. she has the gorgeous, successful hubby. sorry shilpa

    1. Sam at | | Reply

      So your saying, Twinkle has nothing without the man?

      I wouldn’t feel sorry for Shilpa in that case, LOL.

  2. Stuti at | | Reply

    Its a stunning gown, I really cant decide. As a cover, Harper’s Bazaar is much better, but Twinkle is prettier in that gown.

  3. apsara77 at | | Reply

    i think Shilpa’s hair and her confident attitude wins the round for me..and i don’t think having an attractive husband/partner is the mark of a beautiful woman…

  4. Sam at | | Reply

    I don’t really like either…but if I HAD to choose, my vote goes to Shilpa.

  5. J at | | Reply

    As much as I wanted Shilpa to change her hairstyle this is not doing it for me. Seems like an in between look – neither styled nor tousled.

  6. kaya at | | Reply

    The dress is lovely, especially the draping and the way it falls. But this silhouette, color and the dress overall is a very feminine one; it does not work on someone like Shilpa. The L’officiel cover is so beautiful and Twinkle carries it like it as intended to be. If you notice, the model looks tough, yet is once a gain feminine, body language and appearance wise and thus she also makes it wrk.

    The Harpers one is repetitive and pointless.

  7. Praj at | | Reply

    Harpers bazaar- don’t like it at all..
    twinkle akshay- pose is awkward..
    gown color looks nice only on the dior model..

  8. now at | | Reply

    shilpa win this hands down her dusky skin tone compliments the colour of the dress

  9. carol at | | Reply

    the twinkle one lightening is just too much to make them fairer and they are way too airbrushed so i have to go with the shilpa cover atleast she looks real

    1. preeths at | | Reply

      LOL. actually, the first thing i thought when i saw the cover was how un-shilpa she looks. if you see it closely for 5 seconds, it looks like someone has smacked her nose, it looks FLAT. like she fell down on her nose of something and her nose permanently held that position . u know the way we see in cartoons? bad bad BAAAAAADDDD photoshopping

  10. charan at | | Reply

    The only thing about Twinkle and Akshay cover is… Twinkle is giving a dreamy pose and Akshay is smiling for the camera. Shouldnt both look like “they dont know the picture is being taken” kind of pose?? (case in point – Sonam and Imraan)

  11. pdaervo at | | Reply

    Awwww Twinkle and Akshay look cute :) and Shilpa looks good too
    Can I vote for the Dior dress?
    (there’s a reason why Dior is my favorite ;) )

  12. pan at | | Reply

    Both the pics look like they have been photshoped to death! Its almost like the 80’s shoulder pads…. when designers first invented they thought the more the better and would use it to death… only to realize its not so! Photographers please dont make the same mistake!

  13. Pamela at | | Reply

    I think Shlpa does justice to a cover pose for a magazine,plus she looks better in the dress.

  14. fiona at | | Reply

    shilpa looks glamorous and the cover looks high fashion so shilpa wins this

  15. Nida at | | Reply

    Cover-wise Twinkle and Akshay, but of course for the gown Harpers does justice.

    Does Shilpa not remind anyone else of Jennifer Aniston? Like random jhalaks/glimpses? It happened to me again looking at this picture, I feel a little crazy.

  16. sp at | | Reply

    I still the way it looks on twinkle better.. i don’t like shilpa’s expression and the hair is just weird!

  17. now at | | Reply

    u cannot actually see twinkle look properly so shilpa wins

  18. tan ta da! at | | Reply

    ‘best bags and shoes’ is the only creative thing they cud come up with?

    1. annie at | | Reply

      Her name “shilpa Shetty” on the cover seems like an after thought. The editor could have added something to her name to tell the buyers why she is up on the cover.

  19. hamsanat at | | Reply

    Shilpa all the way

Leave a Reply