25 Responses

  1. samantha at | | Reply

    those red lips are not working on the dress for Reshma; as for Priyanka, she’s looking fab!

  2. swati shetty at | | Reply

    love it on priyanka. the red lipstick spoils it for reshma, also the silly steel watch!!!

  3. koel at | | Reply

    This version looks much better than the salwar kurta version.
    The dress is just OK otherwise.

    Both the girls have the same body type so almost looks the same on both of them but if I still have to pick one then I will pick Priyanka because I like her makeup better.

    1. Nishita at | | Reply

      I guess I would pick Reshma just because I like her open smile.

      That said, I think this is an awful dress

  4. Bsimple at | | Reply

    I would have gone with Reshma coz her body type and height is so much better suited to the dress and she fills the dress better…but her garish makeup and unkempt hair kill the look and so by default it will have to be PC…

  5. kaya at | | Reply

    Both are sloppy and out of the sartorial loop. hehe

  6. KK at | | Reply

    NEITHER – Don’t like the dress at alll…

  7. Phoenix at | | Reply

    priyanka for sure

  8. funnybone at | | Reply

    piggy ofcourse……reshma’s lips and nose ring r the root cause of this decision……

  9. elke at | | Reply

    I would say neither…but if i had to pick…i’ll say priyanka…coz it fits her better and Reshma looks a lil trashy in tht red lipstick and nose stud…!

  10. Amber at | | Reply

    Reshma looks stunning! She has a dazzling smile.
    The dress itself is HOT!

  11. Jyot at | | Reply

    This also calls for a three way ditto.
    remember Malaika wearing the same dress. albeit the halter back tie ups she chose to cross in the front and then take it behind her neck .

    Just a different way of wearing the same dress.

  12. pratap at | | Reply

    definately reshma…she looks stunning with a million watt smile…..

  13. lurverlurver at | | Reply

    pc..looks better…

  14. Kiwi at | | Reply

    Priyanka, by far. Also, I personally think that any kind of noe studs/rings give a ‘ cheap’ look

    1. Anu at | | Reply

      Wow, I can’t believe you are the third person to say a nose ring is “tacky” or “cheap” on this post. There are MANY MANY indian women/girls that have had their noses pierced since they were kids, it has nothing to do with a trend or being popular. It’s a totally cultural thing. Sure, it’s varied across India but having a nose ring is considered as a normal thing as having ears pierced in India. Just because all the popular actresses now days chose not to have their noses pierced doesn’t mean that generations of women that have been doing it are cheap or tacky.

      1. the mad momma at | | Reply

        Are you sure Kiwi is indian? Its such a stilted, warped import from the west as far as opinions go!

        Its also quite an insult to cultures where body piercings and tattoos are the norm.

  15. _*Dia*_ at | | Reply

    i cant believe i’m picking priyanka here bcuz of her hair! wow!
    theory of relativity, i guess! ;)

  16. gaga at | | Reply

    i love red lips. both ash and reshma looked lovely in red.
    reshma has amazing legs. (saw her full length pic on an site)

  17. MANGOgrl at | | Reply

    There is too much of details going on in this dress.. this is a very poor version of a pretty Gavin Miguel dress.

    The satin, the flower, the sequence, the embelishment..phew you name it more.. lol

    Also I will not vote for either’s makeup as applying too much kohl in this outfit is very very loud.. this needs a very soft glow makeup

  18. sania chaudhri at | | Reply

    hate the dress…ott..and the halter ewww

  19. the mad momma at | | Reply

    i’d go with piggy simply because the dress fits her better at the armholes. but reshma is the skinny type to looks better in it in real life.

    that said – am shocked by those who think noserings are cheap! they may not match, just like a bindi might not go with jeans. but to call it trashy is just… well, ignorant at some level.

  20. SL at | | Reply

    Reshma Bombaywaywala!

    Without a second thought…

    The red lips are so Hot and the Nose stud even Hotter.

  21. Moh at | | Reply

    Definitely Reshma… fits her curvaceous body better. Just that the red lipstick does not go with the dress.
    Priyanka’s physique is too straight for this dress.

Leave a Reply