49 Responses

  1. emem at | | Reply

    mybe she needs us to be patient..i can definitely see her trying to be stylish,chic and happening – body done.. style sense next maybe.. i like her – so hope she gets it right soon.. these recent appearances have made me cringe here and there..

    1. kaya at | | Reply

      Dear emem,

      I wouldn’t if i were you. You either have it. Or you don’t.

      Or you get a good stylist lol.

  2. parveen at | | Reply

    rani should stop trying too hard. she is an established actress who in the past have shown us that she has an identity of her own. so why all the insecurities now and the need to imitate others? what happened to the confidence, rani?

  3. padma at | | Reply

    i dont mind her shirt and belt, the jeans fit weird, and i never liked those faded streaks, they can be tricky, they only good on tall people with long legs, i think.

    The shades are a different story, for some odd reason she reminds me of a bumble bee with those shades. Didnt like them so much on Kareena either, i didnt like the color of Kareena’s shades on her.

    1. kaya at | | Reply

      Bumble Bee, my first though lol.

    2. Rock~n~Rose at | | Reply

      I agree with Padma.. horizontal streaks just break the continuity and make your legs look shorter, and thats what happened here..

      The bumblebee comment sure cracked me up!

  4. MojitoLover at | | Reply

    ok, why is she wearing shades indoors?

    1. jiji at | | Reply

      lol! didn’t even notice! haha

      1. ramizi at | | Reply

        and that too to an eye event?

  5. _*Dia*_ at | | Reply

    many people bash vidya for wearing anarkalis and kurtas all the time. but atleast she identifies what doesnt suit her and stays to what she is comfortable in. what rani is doing is the opposite. why is she trying to fit in? she looks great in indian clothes and saree is her territory. i love when she wears those clothes and cringe when she becomes a victim of these fashion bloopers. sigh…(this is my longest comment on this site :)

  6. priya at | | Reply

    totally agree with u PnP. Those glares are just TOO huge for Rani’s face and even for her diminutive frame as a whole. i don’t mind the pink/denim combo but those glares and the belt ruin the look completely. this round belongs to Kareena. (You should have made a poll). However, I do prefer the brown shade of the glares than Kareena’s blue.

  7. pdaervo at | | Reply

    uh…no, just no
    Those blue glasses looked FAB on Kareena (and shielded us a bit from her eyemakeup) but this just looks sad

  8. eclat at | | Reply

    The irony and pseudo- ness of this is just too much- why wear shades indoors, and that too, to an EYE hospital event? Was she scared of contracting something? Then why go?

  9. monika at | | Reply

    Rani is looking so old, especially in the close up. Those glares are not suiting her at all.

  10. peppy at | | Reply

    since recent times..everytime she make an appearance i feel sorry for her…amazing actress….tryin tooo hard to fit in!!!poor her…

  11. kaya at | | Reply

    Oh man. Oh man. Oh man. What was she thinking???

  12. kaya at | | Reply

    After viewing this Kareena made me appreciate her appearance a WHOLE lot more.

  13. the mad momma at | | Reply

    hey P&P – two suggestions.
    One – the fine white on black text is hard to read for blind bats like me. If the font were thicker it might be easier. I need to highlight each paragraph to read it!

    Two – the pictures on the MTv site are TOO small. The entire point of critiquing fashion is to be able to see the details and theyre much too small to get a good look at. Perhaps click for bigger pics?

  14. Kat at | | Reply

    She looks like Minni Mouse to me.

    1. Saya at | | Reply

      LOL! yes true that!

  15. sarah at | | Reply

    yea,, but plz put a full length pic,, atleast for th rani fans,, plz plz..

  16. jiji at | | Reply

    Yeah, i noticed the glasses straight away in the photos and thought the same thing – they’re way way way too big for Rani’s face and her face shape is not right for these glasses. They looked perfect on Kareena, i love those blue tint glasses on kareena – saw them at Zurich airport but way too expensive and they look huge in real life too!

  17. deepa at | | Reply

    I dont think Rani looks good only in indian outfits.In this case the shades look so terrible on her that I cant look beyond them! Didnt like them on Kareena either.

  18. Megha at | | Reply

    i despise monogrammed belts and those shades that i loved on kareena look scary here (though i do like the colour)

  19. zak at | | Reply

    she is looking to old
    she is a beautyful actress but she needs to do what she is famous for
    instead of trying to be some one else

  20. Pamela at | | Reply

    Give her a break.The glasses are a tad big but that’s about it.I think the jeans and pink shirt look good on her.She’s probably experimenting because she’s lost so much weight.Good for her.

  21. me at | | Reply

    how can you wear shades to an eye donation campaign?!!? these bollywood bums are the limit. i don’t know why anyone wld use them to promote a real social cause. its not like anyone wld look at wannabe, (bumblebee) mukherjee and think “yes, i must donate my eyes”..

  22. Noorina at | | Reply

    she doesnt need to wear them inside..idk about everyone else, but she keeps failing to impress me with any of her looks recently

    i think personally ive just seen too much of her growing up (im 21) that i only like seeing the new faces now…she seems like shes just trying too hard now

  23. Zee at | | Reply

    These are not good pictures of Rani. There are pictures of same event on other websites in which Rani looks absolutely sensational. The outfit, glasses everything looks good on her. Your idea of fashion is so narrow! You compare her to Saif and say that a girl should not wear pink button downs and denim because a guy owns the look!! Where do I even start on that one?
    And btw, crazy big hair is not always good and can be very monotonous , cases in point Priyanka and Shilpa Shetty. Rani has absolutely every right to try a different look. So far its working for her. This outfit and look is a thousand times better than the fuchsia shirt dress Karina wore few days ago.
    Be real you guys.

    1. pdaervo at | | Reply

      They changed the picture, and she still doesn’t look fabulous at all. You’re making a lot of assumptions- it’s a bit silly.

    2. Rock~n~Rose at | | Reply

      zee.. you really need to re-read PnP’s post.. their opinion is that Rani doesnt ‘own’ the look.. which is the main problem.. and i agree with all the gripes about her hair.. its too limp for her round golgappa face… she needs something with more life and volume.. nowhere has any sane person recommended Priyanka Chopra / Shilpa’s hairstyle..

      oh and btw.. am sure anyone who is not a blind rani fan will see that 9 out of her last 10 appearances have fallen flat.. so i seriously disagree with your comment “its working for her”

      Suggest you take a reality check prior to recommending the same to others…

  24. CK at | | Reply

    I didn’t like this look one bit. It could have been better with the right shades and if the jeans were darker and longer.

  25. palefire at | | Reply

    I don’t know why she is being criticized so mercilessly. ( Yes, I am a Rani fan) This was a charity event, what else do we expect her to wear- take a cue from Priyanka Chopra and turn up at every event in short dresses?? Her frames may have been a little large but don’t we get that they are MEANT to be large. And whoever says Rani can’t pull of western clothes, should go and Rent DVDs of KKHH, Chalte Chalte and KANK.

    1. Carol at | | Reply

      Being a fan does not mean you ignore the fact that she looks ridiculous in those shades especially at an ‘Eye Donation’ event. They are being worn indoors and completely inappropriate not to mention unflattering.

      I have the same problem with Priyanka wearing hoochie mama outfits to events or shows with little kids. I have stated my issues with stars not dressing appropriately for events – favorites or not.

      I do agree that Rani will sometimes look good in western wear but I guess it depends on her stylist selecting outfits that suit her body type and comfort level.

      BTW, I don’t think this site targets Rani unfairly. She has been praised when she gets it right. I do think they do go overboard with the praise for some so-called fashionistas but that is a different issue.

    2. Rock~n~Rose at | | Reply

      She can only pull of western clothes if a stylist or designer makes sure the clothes/accessories/makeup are in order… left to herself she will make these arbid attempts at being ‘mod”

  26. preeths at | | Reply

    am i the only one who finds hair extensions totally gross?

  27. tan ta da! at | | Reply

    that belt is so tacky!!! i dont even want to mention the jeans and sandals!

  28. Megha at | | Reply

    omg are those ripped denims
    *shakes head*

  29. debs at | | Reply

    Its not that bad. its a regular girl outfit…we all have donned a buttondown and denims at some point. and rani IS the girl-next-door type. not everyone has to be dressed to the nines in short tights legers and smoky eyemakeup all the time. The frames are a no-go for her face..true that.

  30. ak at | | Reply

    the worst part of this outfit are her jeans – terrible fit and wash! honestly, i’m shocked she is wearing these types of jeans these days when we have so many choices. and jeans are so tricky to get right sometimes that you might as well forgo them if you’re not in the proper range of stylish/suitable.

    and agree with diya on the desi clothing – if not traditional, at least fusion (nice kurta etc) would have been a better choice.

  31. Anu at | | Reply

    Rani does look funny with those shades…but still this look isn’t that bad…I still cannot get over her horrible dus ka dum appearance…it was soooooo cheap! PnP u should definitely post that one…

    1. preeths at | | Reply

      cheap? you say?

  32. claire at | | Reply

    ok now i just don’t understand some of the comments that say rani is “trying too hard” in that outfit? it’s just jeans and a shirt! she’s dressed like that before losing weight too, there’s nothing out of the ordinary there.
    now i don’t like the fit of the jeans and the belt, so overall it doesn’t work for me but it doesn’t look like she’s trying too hard (unlike on dus ka dum for instance)

  33. preeths at | | Reply

    the frames are like ginormous for her face
    the hair extensions are gross (i always find hair extensions gross)
    cant anyone see that the jeans are just too short and ill fitting?
    just imagine the same pink shirt with classic blue or dark blue straight legged/skinny denims and a nice pair of heels, ditch those glasses and rani would totally rock this look!
    the pink shirt looks fabulous on her!

  34. Shuma at | | Reply

    Some people may have the money, but definitely aren’t sure what to do with it. She is trying too hard…..especially with the sunnies.

  35. Angelysm at | | Reply

    OMG ! Kareena looks much much MUCH better than her ! the sunglasses r too big for her face…the belt is down right tacky…. the pants make her legs look oh so short ! and PLEASE ! look at her FOOTWEAR..ugly pairing !!! errr i could go shopping at a flea market and still come up with a better look than Rani’s.

Leave a Reply