44 Responses

  1. Ratna at | | Reply

    Katrina’s body looks AMAZING. So she gets my vote. But Sonam looks good too.

  2. radhika at | | Reply

    sonam for me. hands down.

  3. Shivani at | | Reply

    Katrina…Sonam’s idea looks too copycat.

    1. Lola at | | Reply

      I am in agreement with you.

      1. sasha at | | Reply

        Yes, its looks more or less like the runway look! So Katrina it is.. and love what the dress does to her body.. Curvalicious :)

        1. Nidhi at | | Reply

          So true Sasha …Katrina proves curves are so important… ;)

          1. star at |

            Totally agree with you..Sonam’s look is very often similar to the runway/offical pics… from accesories to hair…she never puts her own spin on the clothes!

          2. kasthuri at |

            Ya man. I like her curves in that picture.

  4. mona at | | Reply

    sonam, love the hair!

  5. Isha at | | Reply

    I can not believe how good Sonam looks, and more than that, how awesomely she is styled. Each of the pics is making me love the photoshoot!

  6. jiji at | | Reply

    Katrina! Without a doubt owns this one. She makes it look like that dress was made for her body! I know Sonam has been styled accoriding to the runway look but can’t help but feel she’s raided her Dadi’s closet and played ‘dress-up’!

    1. Jay at | | Reply

      If my dadi had a wardrobe like that… I’d raid it too :P xx

  7. HHC Fan at | | Reply

    Sonam’s. So much more varied….and much more interesting.

  8. *S at | | Reply

    SONAM!!!! what a fun shoot…and yes far more interesting!

  9. Roni at | | Reply

    Sonam…..the clothes she wears are to die for….plus she makes her spread so fun!!!

  10. suzy q at | | Reply

    SONAM! sonam gives this dress character….like she gives most clothes in photoshoots (and real life of course) yeah she looks like she raided dadi’s closet, but her expression is so mischevious, like that of a naughty little girl who dadi’ll catch any moment!

    katrina on the other hand, as pretty as she is, always looks the same in every damn photshoot! Like, every shoot she has that same dreamgazing expression, the same hair in every shoot, same figure-hugging dresses, usually kinched at the waist, and at least one smoky eye makeup shot.

    1. shireen at | | Reply

      I agree. Sonam brings it on in the photoshoot and is dazzling. Katrina looks lovely as always but the Harper’s spread is boring.

  11. ariel001 at | | Reply

    I hate how the jacket covers the ruffles on the dress. Katrina looks beautiful. The boots peeking out looks awful though.

    1. annie at | | Reply

      Totally agree! Sonam’s boots are much more edgier. Katrina should have gone for some heels instead.
      Also, I find it pathetic that every month stylists buy just 1 dress and use it in every photoshoot. Do they think people wouldn’t notice?

  12. Layla at | | Reply

    Well, I like Sonam’s as it is more high fashion that Kat’s. Katrina’s look is more glam, like usual, she should switch it up a bit.

  13. pop at | | Reply

    Both? Yes both!
    Katrina’s body looks absolutely amazing! But I can’t help but think put a blonde wig on her and you have Kim Zolciak!

    1. Bhavana at | | Reply

      hahahah..omg i never even realized the similarity between katrina and kim zolciak..that is hilarious!!!

  14. dreamygirl at | | Reply

    Sonam!!! She looks BEAUTIFUL!

  15. Sim at | | Reply

    As hot as Katrina looks Sonam wins this (even if it is very off the runway) the boots work much better with the victorian ish theme. Kats boots are too bulky and look sporty

    1. Monkey at | | Reply

      Kat’s boots look similar to the one from the runway – prefer Sonam’s boots. So much more edgy.

  16. ruchi at | | Reply

    Sonam-ista all the way!!!!!!! Elegant but different….and that smile can make even Katrina Kaif look less mesmerizing!! Everything from the styling to the body language is perfect. P&P, can you put up the other pics from the photoshoot..theyre all fantastic!

  17. Anu at | | Reply

    Katrina- curvy n sexy!

  18. Chica at | | Reply

    SONAM all the way ! her shoot is more fun ! Kats is looking washed out in sm pics.. dint like her make up at all ! Sonam looks gorgeous n so playful !

  19. shyba at | | Reply

    Sonam………for sure….

  20. sanjana at | | Reply


  21. RUCHii at | | Reply

    its unfair to compare the two shoots…both of them looking lovely..Kat in a beautiful-elegant way and Sonam in a beautiful-quirky way.. :)
    BUT..loooving Sonam’s boots..so SEXY..!!

  22. VirgoVixen at | | Reply

    Sonam….undoubtedly. :)

  23. vandana at | | Reply

    sonam’s photoshoot was infinitely better!

  24. diptiN at | | Reply

    my vote goes to Sonam, love the expression on her face and the hair is just so much fun. Katrina looks like a lifeless statue.

  25. wonderwoman at | | Reply

    KATRINA hands down… looks indian n international at the same time

  26. shilpi at | | Reply

    sonam for me ..it looks fun

  27. swati at | | Reply

    Sonam, Sonam, Sonam ….

    … Katrina looks gorgeous but sonam adds so much personality to the outfit . I love the way it has been styled . And since they are both shoots for fashion magazine and not a filmy one – the idea should be to do something new, creative, quirky and not just look plain pretty . Sonam wins it for me.

  28. swedesh at | | Reply

    wow, sonams shoot is awesome, p n p you should feature the story if you can, they are about the trends that well see.

  29. Shweta at | | Reply

    Both spreads are so good! Beautifully styled! Whats disappointing with Sonam’s spread (and most of her looks in general) is picked directly and styled almost exactly like the runway and promotions of the brand in question! No wonder she never gets it wrong!

  30. Orchee at | | Reply

    Actually, the ditto prob makese sense given both mags are owned by the same publisher. I’m constantly surprised at the lack of inspiration, or even old fashioned rivalry (ie don’t let the competition get their hands on the dress)
    I kind of want to see Sonam in that hat!

  31. Natasha at | | Reply

    Love BOTH!! Katrina looks sensual whereas Sonam is very trendy/fashion.

  32. Shekha at | | Reply

    Defo Sonam! Katrina same old boring expression.. while Sonam makes it fun and the pieces she is wearing are to die for

  33. anon at | | Reply

    Katrinaaa! she looks amazing, her body is soo much better than Sonam’s so the dress suits her much better. Sonam just ends up looking daggy and boring.

Leave a Reply