82 Responses

  1. KP at | | Reply

    hate to say this about anamika khanna and sonam kapoor but – yuck

  2. Carol at | | Reply

    Sonam looks pretty even in that ugly dress. Her shoes are too small and the red toenail polish does not go with this princess look.

  3. manisha at | | Reply

    I disagree – I think she’s pulling that red dress off really well. Yeah it might be slightly too bright for a day event, but if a young fashionista like Sonam won’t wear red, who will? :)

  4. Deepa at | | Reply

    Oh, my! She looks so cute. I may be saying this over and over again about Sonam. But I can’t help it. Who wouldn’t want to look like that in all dresses?

  5. comel at | | Reply

    Not lovin’ it (love Sonam though)…Very Edison’ish!

  6. herdisnot at | | Reply

    The bottom part spoils the whole look. It could have been a short fitted black skirt for damage control. Why those sandals, sonam?
    Did Juliet meet Jasmine on the beach someplace?
    Major fashion faux pas for one of my favs- sonam.

  7. Sonali at | | Reply

    She looks gorgeous, love the whole look. I think its rather ideal for brunch, she tones it down with minimal accessorize. Perfect look..

  8. Megha at | | Reply

    dont love the look (the sandals are esp bad)
    but i have to give it to sonam…she makes it sort of look ok
    with anyone else it may have been a wtheyyy

  9. K at | | Reply

    okay, the other day I said Sonam atleast one wtheyyy…

    Well what do you know! What a ugly dress. Certainly not a WTheyyy but its still very bad. And for ONCE Sonam’s makeup and hair ain’t all that….

  10. FPDP at | | Reply

    Apart from those shoes, I love her look. Her face is gorgeous and she carries this Jasminey look quite well. I think wearing orange (I don’t think it is red) is fine for the day.
    @Carol: I think her nails are bare.

  11. PeachBellini at | | Reply

    okay, i’m sorry, but this outfit looks really silly. really.

    the dress could’ve been okay if it weren’t for her hair and shoes. she looks like a birthday girl….who just turned six.

    sorry guys, i know love is blind, but let’s at least try to be rational! i can’t see people looking at someone dressed like that and taking them seriously.

  12. Antonia at | | Reply

    Oh my gosh – it looks as though she is wearing a prom dress. Horrible.

  13. koel at | | Reply

    Lol. Insane. My neighbourhood can make an outfit with better structure. And Sonam Kapoor looks real crappy ‘for a change’ with that funny hairstyle. Guess her stylist must be on vacatiion

  14. koel at | | Reply

    neighbourhood darzi I mean

  15. madhu at | | Reply

    bad hair-check
    ugly dress-check
    wrong choice of footwear-check

  16. Indian Girl at | | Reply

    I love the sandals…not with this dress…but I’d love to own them if they are what I think they are.
    The hair is tres weird

  17. evesy at | | Reply

    She looks stunning! Only Sonam can pull this off…I love how Anamika considers her a muse, but Sona chooses to wear her outfits! Now thats a great muse!

  18. KK. at | | Reply

    she looks beautiful-speaking purely based on her face. The rest is miserable. just because she wears it doesnt make it fashionable.im sorry but that sad excuse for an outfit and miserable hairstyle do absolutely nothing for such a pretty girl. shame really.

  19. Anita at | | Reply

    like the runway version – shade of red, cap sleeves, hair – better, but Sonam looks OK in what would be a disaster on someone else

  20. Gossipgal at | | Reply

    what an ugly outfit.. and no way sonam is pulling off…NO WAY

  21. Ashi at | | Reply

    I love her hair, but that dress just looks all sorts of weird.

  22. KK at | | Reply

    I agree.. too much for a day event. I think this whole look for a night event would’ve looked stunning!

  23. pdaervo at | | Reply

    I acutally like this dress :/ It’s unusual and interesting
    what I don’t like is how he’s worn it (those SHOES D:) and the hair is cute…but paired with the dress makes her look like she’s dressing up as a fairy
    and the makeup is ugly
    not a good look for the day…or the event

  24. pdaervo at | | Reply

    p.s. the model is TOTALLY cute :D
    I love her hair

  25. preeths at | | Reply

    Absolutely hideous prom outfit, bad hair and shoes..yeowww. not even sonam can make this work !!!!

    one thing ive noticed is no matter how bad her appearances are, the post is never labelled as “WTHeyyy” of “On the fence”!!! they are always labelled as “in anamika kahnnas” or “in sabyasachis”… lollll

  26. Nepali at | | Reply

    Anamika Khanna’s design is better than it was when she collaborated with someone else. Keep it up! If you go through the archives, you will find celebs wearing evening gowns to a magazine launch or a product launch; maybe that’s what they wear?! I prefer bright colours for a daytime.
    Coming back to this look, the sandles look bad with the dress, the hair looks like it has some rice grains on it (maybe it looks different in a magnified image), the dress is not bad, the make up is good and she looks fine, super fine.

  27. NJ at | | Reply

    I love the fairytale-princess hair. The dress, not so much.

  28. monika at | | Reply

    Shoes are really ugly. But she looks pretty.

  29. jyoti chandra at | | Reply

    just realized, she does not have a waist

  30. Adit at | | Reply

    full marks for her for trying, yes the dress is a bit much…but you know what she looks good.

  31. akaa at | | Reply

    The dress is not at all great, though the one on the runway looks nice ,, But, am i the only one who is finding Sonam very pretty, especially in the second pic on right??

  32. preeti at | | Reply

    not liking anything here ….sandals are nice , but for another outfit …with this length of gown heels are more appropriate ..also dress is pretty bad at shoulders …..I like the fact that she changes her hair style often , but this one is not working here ….so many thinngs wrong …but sonam still manage to look sweet ….

  33. Nita at | | Reply

    the dress is really experimental….but guys look at sonam….gawwwwd she’s a DIVAAA!!! cant wait for cannes! and please all of you…imagine any other actress carrying off that look. just imagine? i don’t think so!!

  34. Monkey at | | Reply

    Its weird – like a cross between a day dress and an evening dress. Not quite here, not quite there. Simple black heels and black clutch would have helped. The length of the dress is awkward too..

  35. jass at | | Reply

    my god….sonam is soooo beautiful. and i agree nita. these people are getting too critical of her and her dress. personally speaking she’s the most beautiful bollywood actress i have ever seen….and believe me ive seen them all. LOVE YOU SONAA…u rock!

  36. Rhea at | | Reply

    Super ugly dress and what’s wrong with her hair..
    She looks like a little kid in this outfit. I’m not liking it one bit!

  37. jass at | | Reply

    A Fan’s beautiful prayer:

    youre an epitome of beauty. you’re elegance personified. the most precious thing in the world. the last of your kinds was princess diana…the people’s princess. now you shall carry the legacy forward. i hope our beautiful princess gets whatever she desires in life as our blessings shall always dwell upon her. Today we join our hands and pray to god, to give you the grace of greater success in the work you do. May he be always there to watch over you and govern your actions, to lead you to your best and to make your life a useful one.

  38. Pri at | | Reply

    Hey Payal where are her sandals from? I like! Do they come in any other colors????

  39. Pri at | | Reply

    Okay so I have a fashion unrelated question? THis place Olive, it’s in Bangalore and Delhi too right? Well I’ve been to the one in Bangalore when I visited and I loved the food, ambiance and the prices weren’t too bad either… never been to the Bombay one, but how come all the celebs are always there? Will it be crawling with celebrities if I go there? And is it therefore hard to get into and wayyy expensive?????

  40. mia at | | Reply

    horrible dress. sonam still has such a striking and gorgeous face whatever she wears. and i like her relaxed body language.

  41. alisha at | | Reply

    omg!!! y r ppl defending her??? this is u just plain grosssss!!! everthing….top to toe!!! jus luk at her feet, they are falling out of her sandles!!! yuckkk

  42. nicole at | | Reply

    love the way she is looking . god! people whats wrong with u , she is such a DIVA . love her hair its so young and fresh . love her minimalistic makeup its fresh and pretty .

  43. Anu* at | | Reply

    and why should Sonam not be all princessy at this event? Isn’t she their ‘Princess’ Bee right now? (Queen Bee for Loreal = Ash)

    She’s their front face, so I think she can dress like royalty. (but there is no excuse for those trashy shoes) :-)

  44. U at | | Reply

    Hmm.. She does look like a kid playing dress up..

  45. Annnmmmmm at | | Reply

    does she look like a younger version of anne hathaway in teh second picture?

    but don’t like the dress at all.

  46. suchi at | | Reply


  47. MK at | | Reply

    Well she is all that when professional hair stylists, make up artists and a personal stylist are involved, otherwise homegirl is capable of pretty c r a p p y outfits when left on her won. I still remember her totally unflattering choices when she was new in the industry.
    At least her face looks very cute. This whole outfit is just wrong, from top to to the shoes. I cannot imagine a single occasion where it would be ok to wear that.The only saving grace is her face.

  48. MK at | | Reply

    P.S., this dress reminds me of the early 90’s hindi movie fashion. Those horrible puffy sleeve dresses seen on Juhi Chawala, Pooja Bhatt etc. Infact I think this would fit right in the movie ‘Dil hai ki manta nahi’ or may be the godawful ‘Daulat ki Jung’ movie.

  49. cleopatra at | | Reply

    her hair did not look that bad though !

  50. sheeba at | | Reply

    Those flats make her look stunted..And the gown looks like a really bad prom dress.

    Also are “Jass” and ‘nita” the same person….cuz Jass posted a prayer and it was signed as Nita!!
    Didn’t you say something about not letting people write the same thing again and again to prove their point?

  51. koel at | | Reply

    @ Pri. No, it’s not hard to get into. There’s no entry. It’s nicer for lunch for brunch though, but that’s just my opinion. Delhi pone has shifted locations now, now in Diplomatic Enclave. Not expensive, cheaper than a dinner at Hyatt probably.

    and really, the comments out here are getting so juvenile. I knew people live vicariously through celebrities, now I can see it.

  52. CocoNUT at | | Reply

    Were they trying to copy the model’s hairstyle? Cuz if they were, they failed miserably! Her face looks good though.

    The dress is horrible, and it looks even worse with those fugly sandals, but this girl seems to pull everything off!

  53. gossipgal at | | Reply

    @ sheeba.. good catch.. about jas/nita..lol

  54. PeachBellini at | | Reply

    @ MK, funny you mention Daulat Ki Jung, I was just thinking of that movie yesterday (had a song stuck in my head) and even thought to myself that “I don’t think anyone else would even know about this movie”. crazy. but aamir khan was so cute!

    sorry this is completely unrelated to the discussion at hand. @koel, are you from delhi?

  55. melange at | | Reply

    Despite the danger of being labelled a sonam “fan”, I really like her…on second thoughts, I really like her waist up.

  56. Bharati at | | Reply

    MK, lol, another classic of that time was Madhuri’s zindagi ek jua, and of course dil

  57. Dits at | | Reply

    Not nice at all.. I think this is one of those very rare times when Ill say Miss Kapoor misses the mark.

  58. koel at | | Reply

    @ peach..yus yus. You too? Daulat ki jung..hahahaha

  59. Clueless at | | Reply

    I agree with some of the comments here as to why this not in the WTH or On the fence section. Clearly, even the most fierce Sonam fans (& there are quite a few of them here) think this is godawful. If you have lost objectivity then please tell us so that we can take all your future views with a pinch of salt. Pls dont get me wrong but you have created an image of yourselves being fair & this is plain biased.

  60. Clueless at | | Reply

    Are you honestly saying that if vidya balan or sonali kulkarni was in this you would not put this in WTHeyy section?! I am sorry but I find it really hard to believe.

    I also have another gripe (i know its a non sonam related one but i am going to add it here anyway) I remember you guys givings us a speech about your comment policy and have to ask you – have you read the absolutely unwarranted comments on ash and abhi’s pic? everything from she looks like his mother to a double chin and everything in between!? I ask you – how were all these fashion related and what made you approve them?

  61. Shweta at | | Reply

    People, Come on! This is SO not a wtheyy! And I am not a Sonam fan and would never be in a million years, so it’s my unbiased opinion. I like the dress, clutch and sandals separately, just put together it looks weird. The hair is just not working, I applaud her for being experimental though. (the category in which most of her colleagues fail miserably).

  62. Aarthi at | | Reply

    Am a big fan of Anamika Khanna but afraid this is not something I like… But Sonam still manages to carry it off well with her pretty face!

  63. Anita at | | Reply

    hoinestly I do not understand why some comments tend to be so personal – about the celebrity in question. I dont think whether or not you are a fan of someone’s acting skills should have anything to do with how you judge their fashion sense, in a particular post.. Ash post – comments abt her looking like mom were probably offensive – but that was a statement on those particular photos – not on her relationship with her husband as a whole. Just my two cents.. Fashion should and does cross all kinds of boundaries.. and its best kept that way.

  64. Anita at | | Reply

    well I guess i can only speak for myself – do not purport to know others minds..!;-)

  65. MK at | | Reply

    lol@Bharati & PeachBellini
    Yeah, Madhuri’s puffy dresses were the puffiest. Gawwd! I was probably 10 yrs old when ‘Dil Hai ki Manta Nahi’ came out and I used to watch that movie on VCP (not even a VCR) and swoon over Amir Khan and the ‘amazing’ dresses of Pooja Bhatt. Yikes! I have a picture of myself somewhere in a puffy dress which was made to order at the local durzi . Oh, the good,old,puffy sleeved days ….

  66. Nepali at | | Reply

    LOL@melange on label, same here.

  67. PeachBellini at | | Reply

    well said, PnP.

    To a degree, it’s okay to have a debate with fellow visitors, but it’s not appropriate for us to criticize the administrators. it’s not like we’re paying them to do this, they do it for fun, and we’re just benefitting on the side. it’s their blog, their opinion. we’re here to voice ours, not police theirs.

    Clueless, I see where you’re coming from. earlier, it really used to annoy me when I thought Payal or Priyanka was being biased in her judgement. but then i thought to myself, could I do what they’re doing and start a blog that has become so successful today? i think not. so don’t complain and just enjoy their work

  68. diptiN at | | Reply

    I like the dress by itself, especially the color. do not care for the hair, and the shoes do not go with the dress. also the bag is too formal for this outfit. her straight hair, and silver flat sandals would have given the dress a toned down look. there is too much going on.

  69. fashionista at | | Reply

    i think sonam will be really glad that people have the time to comment on her and discuss her so much, on a side not she looks lovely, the shoes could have diff.

  70. Clueless at | | Reply

    @ PnP,

    Apologies for having to continue this… please bear with me a bit longer. For the sake of argument –
    (i am not a fan of any of the ladies in question)

    Going by your “wearer” argument – Vidya & Sonali will never stand a chance of doing anything outstanding because of their far from perfect bodies. If they try something experimental – it will be called a disaster & if they wear what suits them best – it will boring. So its a lose lose situation for them isnt it? Whereas someone like Sonam will get away with just about anything simply because of her body type.. yes fashion is cruel – thanks for knocking that into me.

    @ PeachBellni,

    I appreciate the moderators for what they do, honestly I do. And I know this a purely a hobby. But when one sets out rules and makes a big fuss about them, then I as a regular visitor who’s been following their site since it first began and took their policies seriously – even if its about frivolous matters, have every right to take them up to task if there is a big gap between what they say and what they do.

    As for the success of this site – I think its successful because PnP are knowledgeable and people are interested in and respect their their views. And this is why I think , in order to maintain the integrity of this blog, they need to be objective and more diligent.

    phew… god this is long..

  71. koel at | | Reply

    @ Clueless. Thank god atleast someone here is not following the herd and speaking their mind. It’s funny that Anushka Manchanda looking great has 20 comments and Sonam looking like crap has over 70.

  72. Carol at | | Reply

    @Clueless, thank you. Because someone has the so-called perfect body shape does not mean everything they wear looks good or is appropriate.

    The administrators need to be objective and apply the rules even handedly.

  73. P at | | Reply

    There is some heated discussion going on here !
    @ Clueless:Fashion is cruel but I don’t believe that you can’t dress fashionably according to your body type.I am 5 1″ and not really the skinniest but I do take risks with my clothes and spend some time on what would look good together.So while THIS particular outfit might not look good on Vidya and Sonali,there are so many ways in which they could dress fashionably.I know its probably unrelated to fashion but I do think celebs should make an effort to become fit and toned;not become anorexic and starve but work out and stuff.You are in the entertainment business after all,its your job to look good!That way,I do feel both Ash and Sush have let themselves go,no longer any toned figures.Sonam can do with some toning too but she still keeps my excitement levels high with regard to her fashion,I know I look forward to a fashion post of her’s each time on hhc.About comments,I feel they are ok as long as they talk about physical appearances.Sure if a dress makes someone look bulky,I think its okay to say it makes them look fat ;again that is just my opinion.But what honestly gets me are personal attacks or gossip mongering.On some of the Freida posts,there was stuff abt her ex and how she had no morals,I mean WT hell?Its her personal life and choice.But I think comments like Ash looks like Abhi’s mother are meant to imply she looks older or he looks younger but don’t reflect or comment on their personal relationship.In that regard,I agree with what Anita mentioned but again that is just my opinion.I do understand some comments might annoy someone else.

  74. PeachBellini at | | Reply

    @ Clueless: fair enough.

  75. preeths at | | Reply

    i really honestly believe and have seen that no matter what your body type, you can always wear something that suits you and still look fashionable and beautiful. its all about KNOWING what to wear. and our bolly ladies are very far from that.

    another thing is Payal and Priyanka do give credit where credit is due. eg: soha ali khan, amrita rao or even vidya balan in her white anarkali. we might or might not agree to it but thats only because we have different opinions on fashion.

    However, i also agree to your last point where i have felt several times that the moderators get touchy about the comments posted her and then seem to approve almost everything for certain celebs. i have seen the trashiest comments in some aishwarya rai/lakshmi menon posts and have also seen them defending sonam in her posts or severely moderating in freida posts. at the end of the day, yes its their blog and they have every right to say/do what they want but i sincerely feel a fashion blog has to be totally unbiased :))

  76. Anita at | | Reply

    @Clueless – I respect the fact that you’ve chosen to speak out – But thought I should point out a few things:
    1. I dont think pointint out someone’s double chin to refer to a bad photograph or an unflattering one is the same thing as calling someone “ugly person who cheats on her…” blah blah – One can be libel, the other’s not. Which probably drives PnP to approve/disapprove some posts

    2. Ash and Sonam seem to generate a lot of controversy – its almost as if a lot of people feel they have to belong to one camp or the other. But really, i see no comparison. Ash is in her mid-thirties and probably at the end of a phase in her career. SOnam is just starting out, is young and in a different phase of life. She dresses VERY differently than anyone in tinsel town that I have ever seen – she knows she has the height and attitude to carry the clothes off and she does it!! Aishwarya is from a different “fashion” generation with a different personality – SHe can carry a sabyasachi sari like noone else for example.. I am not sure Sonam would look that elegant in the same thing..

    3. Dont shoot the messenger!!! I defend PnP’s right to have favorites among celebrities.. As long as you get your say, why care???

    very long post.. i forget where i started.. so will end here:-)

  77. VirgoVixen at | | Reply

    There are TONS of ways Sonali/Vidya could dress interesting, be experimental, dress according to their body type and be called fashionable other than THIS particular ensemble Sonam is wearing. It’s a pity that they don’t. And that’s called having style; that you manage to wear what looks good on your body type AND rock it! That is the precise difference between a wannabe person who follows fashion trends disregarding their body type and someone who is original and dress according to what looks good on them. When I go out and look around, majority of people DONOT have a height/face like Sonam, YET some of them manage to look even more stunning than her:)
    Anyway, I didn’t wanna continue this but when I heard you say ‘Fashion is cruel’ I just had to out my 2 cents in, since I don’t agree with that.

  78. preeths at | | Reply

    Just a update PnP

    i checked out other picures of hers from this event and the bottom of the gown is harem style. its not a dress

  79. Kps at | | Reply

    Nothing works for me in this outfit, not the dress itself (a princess dress for a day event, really???), not the hair, not the makeup,nor the shoes…. She even seems to be carrying herself awkwardly….

  80. RasH at | | Reply

    My first comment in the website, I was compelled to do that after seeing this horrible styling by Sonam – dress – bad – shoes even worse, together – yuck

Leave a Reply