29 Responses

  1. abby at | | Reply

    kareena, hands down.
    you know when you have slow loading internet and evrything is revealed pixel by pixel, well, when it was only aisha takia’s face showing i was like, “wow, she looks good,” but as soon as the kareena kapoor image loaded i was like “WOW WOW WOW, kareena hands down!”

  2. Bsimple at | | Reply

    Designers these days seem to be going OTT with Blinggg… its so easy to let bling overshadow any design on the garment ( i mean like motifs, etc) …it just doesnt let the designer’s creative sense to do the talking! Its a rare sight to see some traditional work on clothes these days…It’s like bling is the new embroidery…both are similar styles…the corset/spaghetti like top, straight skirt, broad border on dupatta and the great Manish “pastel” Malhotra…I am bored! Can’t they Bsimple? :P

  3. Foxie at | | Reply

    Ayesha. Kareena has much more attitude but i that doesn’t have anything to do with the outfit.

    Love the red & black of the VP. MM’s pink and silver combo could be so nice if only there were a little less work on the lehenga… its so heavily embroidered that no details show up or stand out… not from these pictures at least.

    but in both – whats with the odd colored dupattas? new trend wot? me no like…

  4. Carol at | | Reply

    Both outfits look gaudy.

  5. nagina at | | Reply

    Both are lovely….

  6. mabel at | | Reply

    ayesha looks like a goddess.

  7. saya at | | Reply

    Vikram Phadnis it is! love the black on red.

  8. nosh at | | Reply

    Ayesha looks amazing. The pattern/embroidery/sequin work is not too overwhelming and she looks proportional in it!

    And I just don’t like Kareena :P She looks so full of herself as usual :P

  9. pdaervo at | | Reply

    Ayesha looks pretty and the cut is really flattering, but I don’t like the pattern or the bling
    I think Kareena’s outfit is hideous, as is her hair, makeup and FAKE FAKE FAKE tan
    …she looks like a drag queen

  10. U at | | Reply

    I don’t like either though I prefer Ayesha’s outfit.. I adore the red and yellow and even the embellishment in it but the black is yerrch. For me Black and colour do es not mix.

    And Kareena’s is yawn worthy and dated. I think wanted something similar in the year 2000. Now, not so much.

  11. Priti at | | Reply

    How much ever I like kareena…Ayesha wins this one for me..infact VP wins..the dress is way better than MM’s version…

  12. Rene at | | Reply

    none period.

  13. Anita at | | Reply

    Ayesha and phadnis..

  14. stylo at | | Reply

    i agree with priti…….. ayesha looked so pretty here and made that dress ( which’s better than MM but not outstanding) stand out .

  15. hotness at | | Reply

    ayeshaaa loookss gorgeousssss!!!!!

    she is so prettyyy OMG
    luv her outfitttt

    kareennaa.///not so much…& she luks fugly as usual

  16. priyanka at | | Reply

    If you look at each separate..the dupatta, the top, and the lehenga, each one is exquisite. Keeping two pieces understated, then adding one of the separate would have showcased the beauty. Like the popular tamil saying goes, even too much amritam(nectar) becomes akin to poison. Way too busy and ostentatious! Vikram could still have worked this outfit if he had a black dupatta with red edging.

  17. Belle at | | Reply

    it’s just way too much. too busy, as people before me have said, @foxie and @bsimple, just WAY too much bling that you can’t actually “see” any design.

    Yeh i agree with u Priyanka…a black dupatta with a red edging would have looked better!

  18. nitu at | | Reply

    ayesha & VP: nothing new, except for diff dupatta which doesn’t add to the outfit (for me anyway)
    kareena & MM: too much going on, no sense of strong connection b/w top, bottom and dupatta

  19. saya at | | Reply

    finding manish’s “new” designs is like watching reruns of ‘everybody loves raymond’
    it’s just not that funny anymore

  20. jaishree at | | Reply

    I think both the outfits are tolerable but not exceptional,nothing striking.Having to choose I prefer Kareenas, its more summerish-like the cream dupatta-love the whole brocade-zardozi combination and MM could have done so much more with it.The dupatta and top look unconnected.While Ayeshas outfit is more matched,the black and red combination is a strict no no for me and very boring.

  21. spee at | | Reply

    I think both the designer (esp MM) are trying the Sabyasachi’s mismatched style. Unfortunately none of two has the same flair about it. MM’s outfit looks way too mismatched.

  22. Raspberry at | | Reply

    Ayesha works it..

    Kareena is gorgeous but she clearly has no idea how to work the runway

  23. Surbhi at | | Reply

    Trust Kareena to be always OTT.. whether its the pose or the costume.. the dress has soo many colours , its makiing me dizzzzzzy!
    Takia seems to have lost weight, like the ghagra on takia.. but thats about it.. the dupatta seems to be taking away the glamour of the dress..

  24. Julia at | | Reply

    Kareena is almost the same orange as that dupatta she’s wearing. But I like how she is posing like a little girl pretending to be a supermodel. Also glad she put size zero behind her…

  25. sqrl at | | Reply

    Love the black, red and gold combination.

  26. Hema at | | Reply

    Ayesha Takia – Phadnis all the way .

  27. Another Kiran at | | Reply

    Both outfits are Delhi wedding gaudy. Enough said.

  28. Prem Rogue at | | Reply

    Ayesha all the way.

    Kareena makes nice dresses look ugly.

  29. Shakta K at | | Reply

    ayesha looks gorgeous! Kareena looks ok.

Leave a Reply