71 Responses

  1. Lola at | | Reply

    Not feeling any of these two choices. The name on the labels matters not, they are ugly creations.

    1. ruch at | | Reply


    2. kasthuri at | | Reply

      Agreed !

  2. Ann at | | Reply

    Not liking either looks. Not my style.

    If I had to pick, I would have gone for sonam’s dress without the sleeves[or make it one sleeved/one shouldered – but definitely not the way it has been presented]. I like bold, structured dresses but teh sleeves look strange.

    1. ak at | | Reply

      not digging either, either. completely agree on the sleeves issue.

      and i feel sonam went horrily wrong knees down with those opaque black tights and pumps.

      what’s with the shiny material on freida’s dress? it looks rather cheap, and that colour is not helping it any.

      1. shina at | | Reply

        agree with the sleeve issue as well as how those black tights are completely killing the look.

  3. annie at | | Reply

    finally get to see them together!! but i am not digging either. they both look tired.

  4. kumar at | | Reply

    oye sonam ke chamchee u two. andhee ho gaye ho kya? how appropo.. pfft! She should be on the WThey arleady! frieda on the other hand looks so chic. love the dress, shoes, makeup n hair.

    1. Vida at | | Reply

      make dat Sonam n twinkle’s chamchees.

      1. fairy at | | Reply

        Real chamcha geeris P&P!!

    2. angl at | | Reply

      LOL!!…agree with every word

    3. anu at | | Reply

      totally agree with u

      1. Rashi at | | Reply

        Lol…. ur so right !! sonam looks like a hot mess here ! and those stockings n pumps.. YIKES !

    4. Ss at | | Reply


    5. SMV at | | Reply

      Ha ha ha …Kumar u r funny…its true both dont loook that great…Sonam even though i wanna like her look…cant like it…its overwhelming

    6. nainadonkey at | | Reply

      this comment is in bad taste.

    7. SS at | | Reply


  5. lucygoosey at | | Reply

    Goose-like Sonam, and fluffy bluebird Freida. Must be the designer dud castoffs. The girls look supersilly in these outfits.

  6. VanillaVibes at | | Reply

    gee…none..both the outfits are quite ugly..wht’s with the goose feather sleeves on Sonam?

  7. kanchanmasi at | | Reply

    Definitely Freida! Sonam looks like she’s trying too hard and i don’t like the result what-so-ever!

    Freida looks charming

    ps: who is the lady wearing Sabyasachi behind freida?

    1. Jay at | | Reply

      Where is the lady behind Freida?

  8. HHC Fan at | | Reply

    I am not digging them either. Too high fashion haha! But I do like Sonam’s hairdo and the turquoise pearl on white!

  9. angl at | | Reply

    the “fashionista” tag has really gone to Sonam’s head. she has completely lost that natural ease that she once brought to her styling. her looks come off very forced for some reason. the pearls don’t look good at all with this type of a dress. the only people in bollywood who have a good style are neha dhupia, dia mirza, and kangana.

    1. arpitha at | | Reply

      rightly said, looks very forced.
      i also agree with Ann’s comment above,her dress is like a birds costume.
      pinto looks better, though her dress is also not that good.

    2. Mysha at | | Reply

      She should go back to her aisha days!
      Her recent appearances are so Whtey!

  10. Sal(SS) at | | Reply

    I like Sonam’s look better. I’m not sure Freida’s shoes quite work with the dress.

  11. SS at | | Reply

    Neither actually. Sonam’s white and cyan color combo looks lovely but that’s about it. The dress itself is weird and she looks like a bird ready to take flight. The black leggings looks horrendous, why on earth could she not skip them?

    1. FashionVictim at | | Reply

      Totally agree with SS…plus the hair and the heavy jewelry is aging her unnecessarily.

      On an aside, the word is “apropos” :)

  12. anu at | | Reply

    Sonam looks bad.. Freida looks gorgeous :)

  13. Smita at | | Reply

    I would go for Sonam though am not liking the tights :)

  14. suhani at | | Reply

    Common, P&P u should scold sonam for that tights

    1. diptiN at | | Reply

      I agree, the tights are pretty bad. I do love her hair, make up and jewelry.

      1. suhani at | | Reply

        I still like outfit paired with jewllery , especially that turquoise necklace… but TIGHTS ,nooooooo

  15. Diviya at | | Reply

    Sonam is trying too hard these days. Frieda fares better, but only marginally so.

  16. monika at | | Reply

    Definitely Freida…..Sonam is looking like a puffed up doll

  17. naiad at | | Reply

    hahahaha Sonam looks like she is about to fly
    Her outfit is such a disaster…

  18. niky at | | Reply

    Sonam: like her appearance minus the sleeves..love freida’s color though…like the tights as well…what’s wrong with that ????

  19. Rash at | | Reply

    God Whyyyyyyy !!! Why on earth did sonam chose that dress !!! Its Horrid its tacky its Whteyyyyy !! All mixed together ! She has disappointed big time ! Freida other way kept it simple and shez looking beautiful and far better than Sonam !

    Just saw the other front row ppl, I am sure Sonam made a joke of herself over there. And I used to love her for her fashion sense .. Sigh :( :( :(

  20. Ramma at | | Reply

    None none, but I can say I think sonams is worse , she is trying tooo hard, looks like a chicken, n those tights r gross

  21. Anu C at | | Reply

    Both look far below their best, but still pick Freida over Sonam. Sonam looks like trying too hard.

  22. ss at | | Reply

    i never thot i wud say dis…bt freida looks wayyyyyy better than Sonam…

  23. leonine lion at | | Reply

    hate both the dresses!!! but what’s wrong with the tights???

  24. shilpi at | | Reply

    Frieda is effortlessly stylish, Sonam trying too hard and this time a fail esp with those black tights

  25. gossipgirl at | | Reply

    come on, P & P, how are you liking Sonam in this??! She looks like that big mother goose in Puss in Boots. Come on, this is a Whatthehey!! put up a poll!

    1. naiad at | | Reply

      “big mother goose in Puss in Boots”
      this comment had me ROTFL

  26. Food poisoned attorney at | | Reply

    Sonam looks bad. I hate the sleeves…combined with the necklaces, the earrings and hair do its alll too much. Frieda fares better bcoz Sonam looks ridiculous otherwise nothing great bat her look either…and the booties were a wrong choice for that dress.

  27. purple at | | Reply

    I think Sonam is wearing opaque tights due to the weather..it’s Winter in Europe.

    1. Jay at | | Reply

      But I thought the show was inside… with lighting, heating… she is driven to 10 feet of the venue and collected straight after… If she can prance around in a sari in rain and snow in films she can whip off the tights and give her dress a chance!

      1. diptiN at | | Reply


      2. leonine lion at | | Reply

        ohhh goddd she’s human, doesn’t have to freeze all the time just because she danced in the snow in a couple of films!!!.. and the dress doesn’t need any chances.. it’s already a fail

      3. Purple at | | Reply

        When they shoot movie scenes, they do one take in like a few seconds then they have their assistants holding a jacket for them to run in to.

  28. neha at | | Reply

    this is a WTHEYYY moment for sonam…..ridiculous outfit.she looks like a hen.and its the worst i’ve seen of freida….

  29. Flower power at | | Reply

    Sonam should have avoided the necklace for sure, and the dress is very unflattering to her shape , Freda looks cute

  30. June at | | Reply

    I have bangkok clothes bought from bandra which look better than both of their looks. I think their hair was made in the dark.

  31. jean at | | Reply

    I like Frieda’s a lil more.. Sonam looks bloated up in this dress.

  32. veenu at | | Reply

    Sonam is looking super silly. ROFLing on the ‘ready for flying’ comment. I am all for the fact that it’s PnP blog and all but still this one deserved a WTHeyyyyyy!

  33. Sal(SS) at | | Reply

    Contrary to what a lot of the other commenters have said, I actually think both dresses are gorgeous, whatever issues there may be with styling/hair/makeup. Also, Sonam’s tights don’t bother me; they’re weather-appropriate.

  34. Mads at | | Reply

    Freida just for that face and smile!! Outfit wise… Both not impressive. Sonam does look like a giant bird about to take off. Freida’s is marginally better.

  35. meria at | | Reply

    WOW! two fashion icons together and definitely not in their best! :/

  36. Apple at | | Reply

    loving Sonam’s look here.. Freida looks a little frazzled but she nonetheless she always looks stunning..

  37. anne at | | Reply

    frieda, sonam looks like she killed a bird somewhere.

  38. Ratna at | | Reply

    I think Freida looks slightly better. I don’t like the tights, the pearl necklace with that dress, the hair (it ages her), and the makeup (too much blush) on Sonam.

    And I don’t think the ladies had that much choice in dresses. I think Chanel PR lend/sent them some dresses to wear to the show.

  39. bhoomi at | | Reply

    Neither one but Sonam’s look is more WTHEYYY than Frieda, atleast the color is working with Frieda.

  40. Sam at | | Reply

    Did Sonam apply her make up in the dark? Awful.

  41. prat at | | Reply

    i am 5 wrong posts away from doubting your taste and style credentials. 1. sonam’s necklaces clash with the busy neck detailing and 2. frieda’s hair n belt just kills it. Girls, seriously, get down to serious fashion dissection and maybe, its time to play down kissing up to these celebs and designers? just sayin…

  42. pegasusbaby at | | Reply

    Definitely Freida over Sonam any day. I love the blue dress – not just the colour but the beautiful, flowy material is gorgeous. It’s just lovely.

  43. Chevalier at | | Reply

    Didn’t work for me – I didn’t ‘get’ either dress though undoubtedly both of them are (supposed to be) chic. At least they didn’t wear something obviously boring.
    P&P: hate to sound pedantic, but the word is ‘apropos’.

  44. VK. at | | Reply

    Loving Sonam’s hair plus the dress with the pearls. Not really a fan of her tights though. I think they make the outfit too dark for my liking.
    Loving Frieda’s dress plus the shoes. Hating on Frieda’s hair though – Looks too messy!

  45. Agam at | | Reply

    I second angl!! Rightly said :)

  46. ig at | | Reply

    freida’s dress is beautiful but her hairstyle for this outfit – not so much.
    sonam looks matronly…her styling does NOT look effortless.

  47. vee at | | Reply

    Well Freida’s seems a bit more down to earth while Sonam’s only looks reasonable on a runway or artsy photoshoot. I can see Sonam is very much into the granny chic craze that’s hot nowadays. I entertained it for a while but now I’m waiting for it to end.

Leave a Reply